Middletown, NY 12455 Homes & Real Estate for Sale


Below you will find Middletown, NY 12455 real estate listings. If you would like to refine your search, use the search form above.


COTTAGE OVERLOOKING PRIVATE 1-ACRE POND: A charming property needing some tlc, but well worth the effort, this unique property consists of two parcels which total 1.96 acres, but the sweet 2-bedroom 1-bath cottage is located at the back of the pond, nestled in the woods, and down a private driveway–a good distance from the road….

864 sq ft 2 beds 1 bath

THIS 1860S VICTORIAN WITH MANY ORIGINAL DETAILS INTACT is nestled on a quiet back street in the village of Margaretville. It features high ceilings, generous rooms, and is livable as is, but cosmetic updates will make this home a complete knockout. It includes a classic side hall Victorian floor plan with turret over the porch,…

1760 sq ft 4 beds 1 bath

SPACIOUS 1850 FARMHOUSE ON 4.7 ACRES conveniently located just minutes from beautiful downtown Margaretville. The charm of this particular property is that, while many updates and enhancements have been added to the original house, the home still retains much of its original historic detailing. For example, the downstairs features a generous living room with a…

2160 sq ft 3 beds 1 bath

INCREDIBLE CROSS MOUNTAIN ROAD OPPORTUNITY: It is so rare that any property comes up in this pristine area of the Catskills, and even more unusual to have one available in this price range. This private 6.24 acre property does need some work to be completed, but the truth is, the hard work has largely been…

1848 sq ft 3 beds 2 baths

HISTORIC 1889 COLONIAL with lots of potential, seeks new owner with imagination. Conveniently located on Route 28 between Margaretville and Andes, the property was once a family-run convenience store and an important resource for local residents. This home is favorably situated within 2.5 hours from the GWB, and just minutes away from some of the…

1364 sq ft 3 beds 1 bath

MILKWEED MEADOWS – Margaretville’s MOST AMAZING BUILDING LOCATION 5+ acres of PERFECTION. Property situated on a CORNER LOT with both roads being TRANQUIL DEAD END locations! This property has it all….MOUNTAIN VIEWS, a LOVELY STREAM, EASY BUILD SITES and absolute QUIET ENJOYMENT. Only 2 miles from the Village of Margaretville but you are ensconced in…

MILKWEED MEADOWS – Margaretville’s MOST AMAZING BUILDING LOCATION 5+ acres of PERFECTION. Property situated on a CORNER LOT with both roads being TRANQUIL DEAD END locations! This property has it all….MOUNTAIN VIEWS, a LOVELY STREAM, EASY BUILD SITES and absolute QUIET ENJOYMENT. Only 2 miles from the Village of Margaretville but you are ensconced in…

Calling all GOLFERS, SKIERS, lovers of all things CATSKILLS, or anyone who loves MOUNTAIN VIEWS. This unique parcel is a lovely mix of beautiful slopes, plateaus and breathtaking stone features located on a quiet DEAD END Road. Some selective clearing will reveal sweeping views of the surrounding peaks. A two minute walk will lead you…

This stunning, renovated cape-cod home is privately situated on 5+ acres of land on a quiet cul-de-sac road in the Catskills. The property has been established as a successful short term rental property, managed by Unwind Catskills. With a strong offer, the furniture and rental related items will transfer to the lucky new owner for…

1524 sq ft 4 beds 2 baths

Powered by Estatik

Receive Emails of New Listings

We add 1000s of new listings daily. Receive email alerts when new properties match the listings on this page